Tax Software vs. Accountant: Which Is Right for You? (2024)

Each year, taxpayers prepare to file their taxes and decide whether to hire a professional or file independently using special tax preparation software to complete the forms. Working alone or using Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) or other personal tax preparers offers varying benefits and costs.

Key Takeaways

  • Taxpayers can choose to prepare their taxes using special tax preparation software or by hiring a tax professional.
  • Tax software generally benefits those with simple tax situations.
  • Some tax preparation software may be free and easy to use.
  • Hiring a professional gives taxpayers expert advice for complicated tax returns.

Tax Filing Basics

The deadline to file taxes is April 15 each year. If the date falls on a weekend or a holiday, the deadline changes to the next business day. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) offers six-month extensions with requests in writing using Form 4868: Application for Automatic Extension of Time To File U.S. Individual Income Tax Return.

Taxpayers can file using tax software—some of which use artificial intelligence (AI)—or hire a professional preparer. The IRS strongly recommends that taxpayers file their annual returns electronically and opt for direct deposit to avoid delays in processing paperwork and refunds.

Military members in a combat zone, part of a contingency operation, or hospitalized due to service in these areas have "180 days after you leave the designated combat zone/contingency operation to file and pay taxes."

Using Tax Software

Many companies offer downloadable tax software that lets individuals complete their taxes at their own pace. The following is a list of some of the key factors you should consider as you decide which program suits your needs.

Most taxpayers choose to file their returns themselves using software because it's easy, cost-effective, and simpler to do. Individuals with one income, a minimal amount of investment income, and claim the standard deduction with a few tax credits and deductions may choose to do their taxes. Many apps and software programs offer free filing services for simple returns.

Price

Taxpayers commonly pay less for a software package to file than hiring a CPA or qualified tax professional. The price of tax preparation software varies for filers depending on the service and how complicated the returns are. Service providers like H&R Block or Turbo Tax offer package options that range from $25 to $120 based on the customer's needs.

Speed

When filing at home, taxpayers can choose when and where to complete the forms. Uncomplicated returns may take less than an hour. Once you've filed, your return is usually sent directly to the IRS and your state agency, for which you get a confirmation email. The best professionals, on the other hand, may take several days to a few weeks to process paperwork and file forms.

Simplicity

Good tax preparation software walks taxpayers through the process quickly and easily and commonly offers online support if needed. Those with only a few deductions, sources of income, or investments can benefit from independently filing their taxes.

Certain taxpayers may be eligible to file their federal tax returns using the IRS's Direct File program. It is available to people in Arizona, California, Florida, Massachusetts, Nevada, New Hampshire, New York, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington State, and Wyoming. You must meet other eligibility requirements to use the program. Details can be found here.

Hiring a Professional

Individuals and businesses commonly hire a professional because the filing process is complicated due to multiple sources of income or deductions. Many use the services of an accountant or other tax professional.

Keep in mind that using a professional often comes at a cost. You may pay by the hour or per return. Statistics show that the national average for a federal tax return with Scheule A and a state income tax return costs $323.

Better Software

Professional accounting software is more sophisticated than the products sold to consumers. These advanced programs can quickly scan information and organize line items and forms correctly. By automating much of the data entry and organization, there's less chance for human error on a tax return.

Expertise

Many taxpayers and businesses develop a relationship with an accountant so that they understand their financial situation and future goals. The value of advice can easily exceed the additional cost of consulting with a professional. For example, a tax accountant can offer advice on tax-friendly ways to save for children's education or how toreduce taxes on capital gains.

Time Savers

Taxpayers who find themselves at the center of complicated business and investment matters may have the skill to sort through their taxes on their own, but is it worth their time? Professional tax preparers are familiar with the system, and they can quickly accomplish tasks that might take even skilled taxpayers hours of research.

Enrolled Agent

The IRS certifies enrolled agents who represent taxpayers and tackle tax matters, like attorneys or CPAs.

What Is the Difference Between a CPA and a Tax Professional or Preparer?

A certified public accountant is a certified tax professional who may choose careers outside of tax preparation, such as private accounting or auditing. Tax professionals or preparers are not CPAs and do not hold certifications, but may be employed by tax preparation companies or the IRS.

Is It Worth It to Pay for a Tax Professional?

That depends. If you have complicated taxes that require special forms and calculations, it may be worth hiring a tax professional to file the forms and ensure that all income, deductions, and itemized items are reported. If you have a simple return that is fairly straightforward without any complex deductions or documents, consider saving the money and filing yourself using a tax software program.

Where Can Taxpayers Find Important Tax Filing Information?

The IRS provides educational information, helpful tips, and online access to an individual's account through their website. You can also find a lot of useful information about taxes and tax filing on Investopedia's tax page.

The Bottom Line

Individuals with a single employer and few investments may save money by preparing their taxes. Those with business income or rental properties will find hiring an accountant worth their peace of mind and potential tax savings.

Tax Software vs. Accountant: Which Is Right for You? (2024)

FAQs

Tax Software vs. Accountant: Which Is Right for You? ›

Finding an Accountant Can Lead to Big Tax Savings

Can an accountant do better than TurboTax? ›

Complex Tax Issues: TurboTax may struggle to handle certain complex tax issues or situations involving multiple income sources, various deductions, or international tax implications. In such cases, a CPA's expertise can be invaluable in navigating the complexities and optimizing tax outcomes.

Is it better to do your taxes yourself or by a professional? ›

If you're confident about your ability to understand the tax code, then doing your own is a smart way to save. If not, it's probably time to pony up the cash and hire an expert. Ultimately, you have to weigh the value of your time and money against your peace of mind.

What are the disadvantages of using tax preparation software? ›

If you itemize your deductions, have lots of investments or earn non-W2 income, tax software may not be the best option, as it could mean missing valuable write-offs or reporting your income incorrectly.

Why might you want to hire a professional tax preparer rather than using tax software to prepare your own return? ›

A tax professional can look at your past returns to see if any deductions were missed and, if so, amend them for you. You can reduce your risk of an audit. And, if you are audited or the IRS starts asking questions you can't easily answer, a professional tax preparer knows how to deal with the IRS.

Will an accountant save me money on taxes? ›

It can be worth the expense, as many people find that they actually save money by going to an accountant because their tax refund increases significantly. But there are also cases where you may want to file your return on your own.

Who is the best person to do my taxes? ›

Certified public accountants: Use the CPA Verify tool or check with your state's board of accountancy. Tax attorney: Contact your state's bar association.

Is an accountant better than H&R Block? ›

A CPA is a licensed, certified professional who specializes in your specific tax needs. Further, they have focused their careers on knowing the ins and outs of up-to-date tax laws and regulations. It is important to understand the services provided by H&R Block may not be the same quality when handled by a non-CPA.

Is using an accountant worth it? ›

CPAs can help minimize your tax bill by taking advantage of all potential deductions and credits you can claim and advising you on tax planning and strategic decisions. CPAs can save you time. On average, it takes more than 10 hours to complete an individual return; complex business returns can take much longer.

What software do accountants use to file taxes? ›

ProSeries is a desktop or hosted product for small to mid-sized firms that supports individuals and small businesses. Lacerte is a desktop or hosted product for large accounting firms with complex returns. ProConnect is a fully cloud-based tax software for accountants.

Is TurboTax ripping me off? ›

The Federal Trade Commission has issued an Opinion and Final Order that Intuit Inc., the maker of the popular TurboTax tax filing software, engaged in deceptive advertising in violation of the FTC Act and deceived consumers when it ran ads for “free” tax products and services for which many consumers were ineligible.

What's the difference between an accountant and a tax preparer? ›

Key takeaways: A certified public accountant (CPA) is a financial expert who helps clients manage their budgets and prepare for retirement. Tax preparers focus on communicating with tax authorities, reviewing tax codes and filing tax paperwork.

What percentage of people use a tax preparer? ›

Most people fill out their tax returns with assistance from paid preparers. In 2015, 53.8 percent of all returns were completed this way.

Is a tax preparer better than TurboTax? ›

Though TurboTax and similar software are set up to analyze your life changes, tax professionals do so with a personal touch. A professional understands the nuances and ever-changing tax codes that impact people with complex tax situations.

Do accountants use TurboTax? ›

TurboTax is only licensed for personal use, and it is not compliant with IRS regulations for paid preparers. Intuit offers ProSeries, ProConnect, and Lacerte Tax software, which are IRS-compliant for tax professionals who are filing multiple returns.

Is it better to use CPA or accountant? ›

Accountants are legally allowed to prepare tax returns, although they may not have as much knowledge of tax codes as a CPA does. Another important distinction is that CPAs can represent clients in front of the IRS in the event of a tax audit, and they can sign tax returns, whereas non-CPA accountants cannot.

Do professionals use TurboTax? ›

TurboTax is only licensed for personal use. Both the license agreement and IRS regulations prohibit TurboTax to be used by paid preparers. Intuit offers ProSeries for professional use that meets IRS rules for professionals.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5485

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.